Just Like Bennigans Sandwich Copycat Recipes

facebook share image   twitter share image   pinterest share image   E-Mail share image

BENNIGAN'S MONTE CRISTO SANDWICH



Bennigan's Monte Cristo Sandwich image

My local Bennigans closed down over a year ago. I used to treat myself to my favorite sandwich of all time - The Monte Cristo. No one made it like they did! Had a craving for one and decided to do some research online and found the recipe! I used honey cured meats instead of just the regular meats and it came out AMAZING!!...

Provided by Holly Watson

Categories     Sandwiches

Time 35m

Number Of Ingredients 18

SANDWICH
9 slice whole wheat bread
3 slice honey cured turkey breast (luncheon meat)
3 slice honey cured ham (luncheon meat)
3 slice american cheese (white or yellow - does not matter)
3 slice swiss cheese
BATTER
1 egg
1 to 1&1/4 c water
1/2 tsp salt
1 tsp sugar
1 & 1/2 c flour (all-purpose is fine)
1 Tbsp baking powder
vegetable oil (for deep frying)
powdered sugar (for dusting on top)
toothpicks (4 per sandwich)
DIPPING SAUCE
raspberry preserves

Steps:

  • 1. Separate the 9 pieces of bread on a cutting board.
  • 2. Put 3 slices of bread aside.
  • 3. Using the remaining 6 slices: On 3 pieces place one slice Turkey and one slice Swiss cheese. On the other 3 slices of bread; place one slice Ham and one slice American cheese.
  • 4. Using the 3 slices of bread you set aside earlier; layer the sandwich. (Should be Turkey/Swiss, bread, then Ham/American layer) Will be a triple decker sandwich. Will make 3 sandwiches.
  • 5. Place a tooth pick in each corner of the sandwiches so the sandwiches will hold together. (4 per sandwich - Total of 12 toothpicks).
  • 6. Crack egg in a medium/large mixing bowl. Add water and beat together until fully mixed.
  • 7. Add salt,sugar, baking powder, and flour and stir until batter is smooth.
  • 8. Dip sandwich in batter. Carefully cover all sides and surfaces. (Make sure every surface of the sandwich is covered in batter or it wont fry right)
  • 9. Carefully place in hot oil.
  • 10. Fry until golden brown (usually 3-5 minutes per side).
  • 11. Once it is golden brown remove from hot oil and place on a paper towel to drain off excess oil.
  • 12. Let cool for a few minutes.
  • 13. Remove the toothpicks.
  • 14. Slice in half, or into fourths.
  • 15. Put on a plate and dust with powdered sugar.
  • 16. Serve with a side of Raspberry preserves for dipping!
  • 17. Enjoy!!! :)

More about "just like bennigans sandwich copycat recipes"

MONTE CRISTO SANDWICH {BENNIGAN’S COPYCAT} - I AM …
May 7, 2021 Having worked in a Bennigan’s kitchen in the late 80s, the Monte Cristo is three slices multigrain bread, a layer of ham, a layer of turkey, Swiss …
From iamhomesteader.com
  • Assemble sandwiches on a work surface. Start with one slice of bread, three slices of turkey, 1 slice of Swiss cheese, another slice of bread, three slices of ham, 1 slice of American cheese and one final slice of bread.
  • Pour about 2 inches (or more) of oil into a large pot (enough to cover the sandwich) and set it over medium heat. Heat the oil to a temperature between 325°F-350°F.


COPYCAT BENNIGAN'S MONTE CRISTO RECIPE | CDKITCHEN.COM
Place one slice of bread on a work surface. Top with 1 slice of turkey, 1 slice of Swiss cheese, another slice of bread, 1 slice ham, 1 slice American cheese, and another slice of bread.
From cdkitchen.com


BENNIGAN'S - TOP SECRET RECIPES
Nice work. You just found recipes for all your favorite famous foods. Bestselling author and TV Host Todd Wilbur shows you how to easily duplicate the taste of iconic dishes and treats at …
From topsecretrecipes.com


BENNIGAN'S BUFFALO CHICKEN SANDWICH - TOP SECRET RECIPES
1. Preheat the oil to 350 degrees F in a deep fryer or a large frying pan over medium heat. Use just enough oil to cover the chicken breast. 2.
From topsecretrecipes.com


JUST LIKE BENNIGAN'S SANDWICH COPYCAT - SNAPCALORIE.COM
Just Like Bennigan's Sandwich Copycat Recreate the irresistible flavors of a restaurant favorite with this "Just Like Bennigan's Sandwich Copycat" recipe. This indulgent Monte Cristo …
From snapcalorie.com


CHEDDAR'S MONTE CRISTO SANDWICHES RECIPE - SECRET COPYCAT …
Mar 5, 2025 Bennigan’s Monte Cristo Sandwich is a deep-fried sandwich filled with turkey, ham and cheese, dusted with powdered sugar, and served with raspberry preserves for dipping. …
From secretcopycatrestaurantrecipes.com


SANDWICH RECIPES | GOOD FOOD
Dive into our club sandwich recipes, vegan sandwiches and festive Christmas sandwiches, ... Pile steak, onion, peppers, cheese, ketchup and mustard into rolls to make these American-style …
From bbcgoodfood.com


BENNIGAN'S MONTE CRISTO - MOMMY MUSINGS
Jul 29, 2008 Update: Possibly some good news for old-school Bennigan's fans! It seems the casual dining chain is trying to make a comeback and there are more than a dozen new …
From mommymusings.com


BEST BENNIGAN'S RECIPES - RECIPES.NET
For sandwich lovers, the Bennigan's Turkey O'Toole and Bennigans Buffalo Chicken Sandwich are must-tries. Indulge in the hearty Bennigans Baby Back Ribs or the comforting Bennigans Loaded Baked Potato Soup. Don't miss the …
From recipes.net


JUST LIKE BENNIGANS SANDWICH COPYCAT RECIPES
Place third slice in-between and secure the triple-decker sandwich in the corners with toothpicks. Place egg in mixing bowl, add water and beat together. Add salt, sugar, flour, and baking powder.
From tfrecipes.com


COPYCAT BENNIGAN'S MONTE CRISTO RECIPE: MAKE IT AT …
Dec 5, 2023 Just prepare and cook the sandwiches per the recipe instructions and allow them to cool completely. Place a paper towel on the bottom of an airtight container and lay the sandwiches on top. Cover with more paper …
From copykat.com


BENNIGAN'S MONTE CRISTO SANDWICH COPYCAT RECIPE
Apr 28, 2014 Great for paninis and more – Use this panini press to try savory sandwiches, quesadillas and sweet fruit Turnovers. Use the lock top lid to Warm personal pizzas or open face sandwiches like bruschettas.
From secretcopycatrestaurantrecipes.com


BENNIGAN'S TURKEY O'TOOLE - SECRET COPYCAT RESTAURANT …
Aug 2, 2022 Bennigan’s Turkey O’Toole Recipe. Bennigan’s Turkey O’Toole is a sandwich made with roasted turkey, Swiss cheese, crispy bacon, lettuce, tomato, and honey mustard dressing, served on toasted bread. Make our Bennigan’s …
From secretcopycatrestaurantrecipes.com


JUST LIKE BENNIGAN'S SANDWICH - COPYCAT RECIPE
Get full Just Like Bennigan's Sandwich - Copycat Recipe ingredients, how-to directions, calories and nutrition review. Rate this Just Like Bennigan's Sandwich - Copycat recipe with 3 slices …
From recipeofhealth.com


COPYCAT BENNIGAN'S TURKEY O'TOOLE
A good sandwich is simple, yet packed with flavor and depth. This Copycat Bennigan's Turkey O'Toole sandwich recipe is a classic combination with a spin. This easy sandwich recipe features sliced turkey, Swiss cheese, loads of …
From allfreecopycatrecipes.com


BENNIGAN'S MONTE CRISTO SANDWICH RECIPE BY TODD WILBUR - TOP …
Menu Description: "Smoked ham, smoked turkey, two cheeses, battered and fried until golden with raspberry preserves and dusted with powdered sugar.". When pondering casual chains …
From topsecretrecipes.com


17 BEST COPYCAT SANDWICHES - HOW TO MAKE FAST FOOD …
May 24, 2025 Making these 17 copycat sandwich (and sandwich-adjacent, hellooo Hot Pockets) recipes. Trust us, they look AND taste incredible. Trust us, they look AND taste incredible.
From delish.com


CRISPY FRIED TRIPLE-DECKER SANDWICH: BENNIGAN’S COPYCAT DELIGHT
Oct 10, 2024 recipes Crispy Fried Triple-Decker Sandwich: Bennigan’s Copycat Delight Last Updated: October 10, 2024. 0 0 3 minutes read 0 3 minutes read
From lovewithrecipes.com


COPY BENNIGAN'S FAMOUS MONTE CRISTO SANDWICH - CHEFMELT
May 6, 2025 Take everyday cold cuts and cheese to a whole new level with this crispy fried sandwich that's just as good as the one from Bennigan's. You'll love how the turkey, ham, and …
From chefmelt.com


COPYCAT SANDWICH & BURGER RECIPES - TOP SECRET RECIPES
Recently, Bennigan's restaurants across the country have been closing, but with this secret formula you can still experience the taste of the chain's signature sandwich. Try more of my …
From topsecretrecipes.com


CRISPY MONTE CRISTO SANDWICH RECIPE - BENNIGAN'S COPYCAT
Feb 13, 2025 This Bennigan's copycat Monte Cristo sandwich features three layers of honey wheat bread stuffed with turkey, ham, Swiss and cheddar cheese. The sandwich is chilled, …
From cookingkeys.com


BENNIGANS RECIPES - SECRET COPYCAT RESTAURANT RECIPES
Benihana Recipes (22) Bennigan's Recipes (14) Bertucci's Recipes (7) Biaggi’s Ristorante Italiano Recipes (6) Big Bowl Recipes (6) Big Boy Recipes (2) BJ's Restaurant & Brewhouse Recipes …
From secretcopycatrestaurantrecipes.com


THE MONTE CRISTO: A DELICIOUS CLASSIC – COPYCAT TAKEOUT
Jun 9, 2025 Ingredients. 4 slices of bread – to make the French toast; 2 slices of ham – adds a savory flavor; 2 slices of turkey – for a delicious protein boost; 2 slices of Swiss cheese – …
From copycattakeout.com


Related Search